I posted this blog yesterday after a very, very long and
disheartening week. This morning, I
removed the post, which I am now reposting. One of the commenters to the post
was a former student of mine, whose identity was anonymous. That student's comment
inspired a response that was unfairly polarizing, and I felt, not conducive to a real
discussion. There’s no point in attacking people because they misspell a word
or use a misplaced modifier. There’s also no appeal to pathos here- I am not
asking for anything- I like my job. I love my students. I like my administrators. Much of this is out of their hands.
Frankly, this
post was not meant to start a discussion.I am merely posting my thoughts. It's just me, ranting to the
clouds because I am frustrated with the direction public education is
taking. Here is the post in it’s
entirety.
Dear ____________,
You must know by now that there is an epidemic. An epidemic
of counting days till summer, days till
retirement, days till another career can be had. Out of the five colleagues I
chatted with today, four are thinking of leaving the profession. These are
teachers with nearly 10 years apiece in.
Most of us don’t mind giving up time, squeezing in an extra
hour or two after school or coming in on Saturday. Most of us show up to the
conference days hoping we will actually talk about something that will help
kids. Instead we are treated to instructions on how to test kids, how to test
kids more often, how to analyze data, enter data, collect data. The only thing
this data will do is make some politician -whose kids go to private schools-
look better when they run for re-election.
The president wants us to test kids more often- 4 times a
year instead of once or twice, so we can help the testing companies and their
consultants make money selling tests, curriculum and other programs to schools.
The governor wants to break our union so we can go back to
earning $30,000 a year with no benefits, which will cause many of us to take
second jobs so we can pay off our student loans.
Our administrators want us to get every child to pass,
develop “relationships” with students, and gather data on everything we do. We
are supposed to help grow every child’s individual strengths and strengthen
their weaknesses, while keeping the group in cohort so they can be measured for
school statistics. Oh, and make learning fun.
Most of us went into teaching because we like kids. And the
kids are why we stay: the girl who asked “How are you doing?” after taking a
day for bereavement leave. The kids that are so passionate about a topic that
they stand up in class to make a point. The shy kid who finally smiled and
started talking. The immigrant’s kid who stays after every Tuesday to learn to
write better. The kids who have nothing
waiting at home but trouble, and want to stay after because it’s safe here.
We have been called lazy, stupid, self-serving rubber-room
dwellers by the public, and nobody stands up for us. Not parents. Not
administrators. Not politicians. We are the whipping posts for the New Economy:
educated, salaried, benefited. We are an anachronism in the New Economy.
We wanted to teach them something important, like how to
appreciate a story, or how to write well, or how to calculate geometry or learn
a foreign language. Instead, we are short-tempered, frazzled, dehydrated,
stressed. We loathe the new regulations, but we loathe what we are becoming
more: apathetic. You tell us we are worthless often enough, and we will start
to believe it. Good teachers will leave, and something valuable will be lost.
And then we will have a crisis in education.
It is good to know that your soul is still alive, even if beaten down. From this, wise administrators might realize that by serving and supporting good teachers, they better serve the students. But perhaps the best thing to come out of this writing is that your students might learn that it is courageous to be vulnerable, and that the only way out of fear is through, all via compassion for others. Your bravery to repost a message of compassion, is the best lesson your students [and bosses] can learn.
ReplyDeleteMy sister is a teacher, and chose to get that degree after the kids were well on the way to grown (in other words, she was a grownup), and was so passionate and excited about the work. It breaks my heart to see her so worn down, and to see the loss of hope, in so few years. She loves kids. And there are too many roadblocks for that love to be enough. It's wrong.
ReplyDeleteTruth. Sad, disheartening truth, but truth by any measure. Know that you are making a difference though, surely to some.
ReplyDeleteI reconnected with my 5th grade teacher this year, on Facebook of all things. After we got reacquainted (and I learned that she was amazingly alive and not a hundred years old back then, but instead a new teacher on her first ever assignment at 23) I told her something I never told her then--that she made a difference. She helped me, changed me, challenged me and protected me at a time when I needed a bit of all that.
I had skipped 4th grade and was the youngest in my class by far; a geek, a brain, a weirdo, that kid, and she let me know I could do whatever I dreamed. Her name leapt to my lips when President Obama said in a speech "we all know a teacher who has mattered." And she is now the answer to one of my security questions when I forget a password.
I don't know what to say that doesn't sound insufficient in my own ears. You are a great teacher and a better person and plenty of people know it, including many of the young hearts and minds you so fervently hope to influence. We'll start with that.
ReplyDeleteSome people were born to learn and then teach. You are definitely one of them.
ReplyDeleteThanks, friends, for your kind words. I must reiterate that I'm not looking for pats on the back, or praise. Just the end of a bad week, in a series of bad weeks that I hope will get better.
ReplyDelete